1. What is short selling and why is it controversial?
Short selling is the practice of betting that a listed company's share price will drop. This is typically effected by the person who is placing the bet (usually a hedge fund) borrowing shares which it then sells and subsequently buys back at a lower price in the future. The hedge fund will then return the shares that it borrowed to the lender and will pocket the difference between the price at which it sold and then bought the shares. Critics argue that speculating on a price drop is unethical and can destroy value for long-term investors. In times of market stress, regulators have introduced temporary short selling bans and/or market restrictions on short selling as a way to moderate falling share prices.
2. How is short selling regulated in the UK?
In the UK, regulators have said there is no evidence to suggest that short selling has been a driver of market falls. Indeed the Financial Conduct Authority has emphasised the important role that short selling can have in properly functioning markets. Examples such as NMC in the UK and Wirecard in Germany have supported this thesis. However, short selling has come under increased scrutiny since the very public GameStop saga earlier in the year, which has already triggered a review by the Securities and Exchange Commission in the US. Following this, it is likely that regulatory bodies in other countries will be looking closely at what can be done to improve transparency in the market.
3. Disclosure obligations in the UK
In the UK, a private notification to the FCA must be made when the net short position relating to shares reaches 0.1% of the issued share capital of the company, and again at each 0.1% above that. A public disclosure is triggered at 0.5% and each 0.1% above that. Public disclosures can be found on the FCA's website.
4. Targets for 2021?
There are record amounts of money chasing SPAC and ESG opportunities and we're already seeing SPACs and certain ESG-friendly companies being targeted by short sellers. Investors will be watching closely for SPAC founders rushing into unattractive deals in a saturated market and companies over-selling their ESG credentials. As regulators play catch-up to hold companies accountable for the ESG claims they make, short sellers will continue to target the pockets of overvaluation.
5. The Big Short
Based on the book by best-selling author, Michael Lewis (of Moneyball and The Blindside fame), the 2015 film, starring Christian Bale, Steve Carell, Ryan Gosling and Brad Pitt, tracks the lives of several financial-industry professionals in the mid-2000s as they predict the collapse of the housing bubble. Based on true life stories, these individuals made millions by betting against (shorting) the housing market. The film employs some unconventional techniques to explain complex financial terms – Ryan Gosling uses Jenga to explain tranches in mortgage-backed securities, Selena Gomez explains the ripple effect caused by collateralised debt obligations during a game of blackjack, and, in a cameo appearance, Margot Robbie explains sub-prime mortgage-backed securities, whilst in a bubble bath, drinking champagne. Another wonderful example of the financial world meeting Hollywood.
With close to 600 M&A lawyers around the world, White & Case is an M&A powerhouse and one of the most active M&A practices among global law firms – ranked among the top 3 firms for global M&A by deal value for 2016-2020. We are equally adept at advising on big ticket, complex M&A deals as well as on mid-sized and smaller deals for strategic clients in EMEA and the rest of the world. Led by M&A heavy hitters, with a deep bench of public M&A and PE specialists with an established record advising targets and bidders on takeover offers and schemes. We also have extensive experience advising on strategic acquisitions of significant minority stakes and hostile takeovers, and market-leading debt and equity capital markets capabilities. We provide expert advice to help navigate complex situations, offering innovative financing solutions for both bidders and targets (including advice on PIPEs, high yield and structured finance).
White & Case means the international legal practice comprising White & Case LLP, a New York State registered limited liability partnership, White & Case LLP, a limited liability partnership incorporated under English law and all other affiliated partnerships, companies and entities.
This article is prepared for the general information of interested persons. It is not, and does not attempt to be, comprehensive in nature. Due to the general nature of its content, it should not be regarded as legal advice.
© 2021 White & Case LLP