CALIFORNIA CLIMATE DISCLOSURE LAWS: NINTH CIRCUIT FINDS SB 253 SCOPE 3 REQUIREMENTS AND SB 261 LIKELY UNCONSTITUTIONAL; SCOPE 1 AND 2 REQUIREMENTS PROCEED

Alert
|
7 min read

On November 9, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued its long-awaited opinion in the challenge to California Senate Bills 253 (the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act) and 261 (the Climate-related Financial Risk Act) brought by the US Chamber of Commerce and other business groups (the “Ruling”).1 The Ninth Circuit concluded that the SB 253 Scope 3 emissions requirements and SB 261 requirements likely violate the First Amendment and should be preliminarily enjoined – and that SB 253’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions requirements may remain in effect.2

The plaintiffs originally sued California officials in their official capacities in US District Court for the Central District of California to block enforcement of the laws, arguing that they violate protections against compelled speech under the First Amendment. In August 2025, the district court denied the plaintiffs’ request for preliminary injunctions blocking both of the laws and the plaintiffs appealed. In the Ruling, the Ninth Circuit affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded the case to the district court to determine whether the SB 253 Scope 3 requirements can be severed from the law.

This Ruling bolsters the idea that Scope 1 and 2 emissions disclosure requirements pass legal muster, but Scope 3 emissions disclosure requirements are more problematic. Notably, if the district court determines that SB 253’s Scope 3 requirements are not severable – the court could issue a preliminary injunction enjoining not only the Scope 3 requirements, but also SB 253's Scope 1 and 2 requirements. The Ruling may serve as another reminder to policymakers crafting climate disclosure requirements that inclusion of Scope 3 requirements could hinder their efforts. The Ruling may also be a guide for future challenges to other states’ climate disclosure requirements.

Companies had been preparing for the requirement to disclose five categories of Scope 3 emissions beginning in 2027, and the California Air Resources Board (“CARB”) was set to unveil its proposed regulatory package for Scope 3 reporting this fall. We expect CARB to address the Ruling in a public statement. 

Entities in scope of SB 253 should continue to comply with the current reporting deadlines (i.e., November 10, 2026) for Scope 1 and 2 disclosures and should monitor the district court’s forthcoming severability determination and resulting orders, together with CARB’s announcements and ongoing rulemaking for 2027 and beyond. The Ruling provides a basis to reassess preparations for SB 253 Scope 3 reporting starting in 2027; however, entities should monitor further proceedings before deciding whether to pause that work – and entities may have other incentives to continuing to prepare such disclosures regardless of the fate of SB 253’s Scope 3 provisions (e.g., entities may be subject to existing or forthcoming Scope 3 requirements in other jurisdictions or stakeholder focus on Scope 3 reporting).

Entities in scope of SB 261 should also monitor further developments. Enforcement of SB 261 has been enjoined by the Ninth Circuit pending appeal since November 18, 2025, and the Ruling found that preliminary injunctive relief is warranted, but the ultimate fate of SB 261 remains subject to further legal proceedings.

BELOW ARE THE KEY TAKEAWAYS FROM THE RULING

  • SB 253 Scope 1 & 2 requirements are not enjoined and remain in effect. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial of a preliminary injunction for those requirements. 
  • The Ninth Circuit held that SB 253’s Scope 1 and Scope 2 requirements regulate commercial speech because they compel disclosure of factual information on emissions generated through the respective reporting entities’ own operations (including purchased energy consumption) and bear on capital transactions. Applying intermediate scrutiny, the three-judge panel concluded that the State demonstrated substantial interests in mitigating information asymmetries for investors and reducing emissions,3 and that the Scope 1 and 2 requirements likely directly advance those interests and are no more extensive than necessary.
  • The deadline for reporting entities to file Scope 1 and 2 disclosures (or eligible statements of non-reporting) was November 10, 2026. The Ruling does not impact that legal requirement.
  • SB 253 Scope 3 requirements are expected to be preliminarily enjoined by the district court, as the Ninth Circuit determined them to be “likely unconstitutional” under the First Amendment.
  • The Ninth Circuit held that because SB 253’s Scope 3 requirements concern diffuse party conduct in the value chain, they are “insufficiently tethered to the reporting entity’s own operations and capital transactions to qualify as commercial speech” and are subject to the higher standard of strict scrutiny, which the panel found they fail. Because the panel determined that SB 253’s Scope 3 provisions are “likely unconstitutional,” the panel reversed the district court’s denial of a preliminary injunction against Scope 3 requirements and remanded to the district court to determine whether those provisions are severable from the law.
  • Although SB 253 contains an express severability clause, the Ninth Circuit left that question to the district court. The determination of the district court on severability will affect the scope of preliminary relief, including whether an injunction is limited to Scope 3 or also extends to Scope 1 and 2 disclosure requirements.
  • With regard to primary vs. secondary data supporting Scope 3 calculations, the Ruling states that a company “must either collect emissions data from third parties across its value chain—data that…may be difficult to verify and prone to error—or rely on the same estimates that the State contends are inadequate for Scope 1 and 2 emissions. And nothing in the record indicates that estimates derived from industry averages or proxy data differ materially from, or are more reliable than, estimates the State or the public could independently generate.” SB 253 does not require primary data for Scope 3 calculations. Notably, the Ruling also concluded that, although Scope 3 emissions “may distantly affect a firm’s value, their connection to the reporting company’s specific risk exposure or profitability is too remote to make them pertinent to actual or potential investors.”
  • The Ninth Circuit held that SB 261 likely violates the First Amendment and reversed the district court’s denial of a preliminary injunction as to the law. SB 261 is expected to be preliminarily enjoined by the district court. See Alert: Enforcement of SB 261 was already enjoined pending appeal. 

  • The Ninth Circuit held that SB 261 compels non-commercial speech by requiring covered entities to disclose subjective ideological assessments regarding climate-related risks and make predictive judgments about future economic conditions and “normative assessments about competing priorities and values,” requiring them to “go beyond providing economic information tethered to any commercial transaction” and “share value-laden judgments on a politically fraught subject.” The panel further concluded that the State had failed to demonstrate that those disclosures would reduce emissions. Applying strict scrutiny, the panel held that, even assuming overcoming information asymmetries and reducing emissions are compelling state interests, SB 261 fails on tailoring grounds because the State could have employed less restrictive means to accomplish its goals. For instance, the panel noted that the State could have directly regulated emissions, incentivized emissions reductions or encouraged voluntary disclosures.

  • CARB’s current position is that it will not enforce SB 261 at this time. The Ruling is expected to maintain that non-enforcement position as the litigation returns to the district court. Entities may voluntarily publish SB 261 reports.

  • Preliminary, not final, relief. The Ruling does not permanently invalidate either law; it addresses whether, and to what extent, enforcement of the laws should be temporarily blocked while the lawsuit proceeds at the district court level.

  • Petitions for rehearing or rehearing en banc are due within 14 days after entry of judgment. The parties to the appeal may also seek US Supreme Court review.

This article is part of a series on the California climate disclosure laws. For more information, see our previous articles:

1 Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, No. 25-5327 (9th Cir. 2026). 
2 The Ninth Circuit found that the plaintiffs would suffer irreparable harm absent preliminary injunctive relief against SB 253’s Scope 3 requirements and SB 261.

3 The Ninth Circuit rejected California’s other asserted interest, finding that “the record does not show that companies discussing climate change routinely engage in misleading speech.” 

Top